Which states have produced the most college football All-Americans from 2015-19?
By John Scimeca
Football All-Americans by state (per capita) from 2015 to 2019
- Hawaii: 1 per 472,000
- Louisiana: 1 per 775,000
- Georgia: 1 per 885,000
- Delaware: 1 per 973,000
- Alabama: 1 per 1.23 million
- New Jersey: 1 per 1.27 million
- Texas: 1 per 1.32 million
- Wisconsin: 1 per 1.455 million
- Kansas: 1 per 1.457 million
- Ohio: 1 per 1.46 million
- Mississippi: 1 per 1.49 million
- Utah: 1 per 1.60 million
- South Carolina: 1 per 1.72 million
- Washington: 1 per 1.90 million
- Florida: 1 per 1.95 million
- Tennessee: 1 per 2.28 million
- Arkansas: 1 per 3.02 million
- Nevada: 1 per 3.08 million
- Iowa: 1 per 3.16 million
- Illinois: 1 per 3.17 million
- Pennsylvania: 1 per 3.20 million
- Michigan: 1 per 3.33 million
- Indiana: 1 per 3.36 million
- Connecticut: 1 per 3.57 million
- Oklahoma: 1 per 3.96 million
- Virginia: 1 per 4.27 million
- North Carolina: 1 per 5.24 million
- Colorado: 1 per 5.76 million
- Maryland: 1 per 6.05 million
- Missouri: 1 per 6.14 million
- Massachusetts: 1 per 6.89 million
- Arizona: 1 per 7.28 million
- California: 1 per 13.17 million
- – .51 Wyoming, Vermont, District of Columbia, Alaska, North Dakota, South Dakota, Rhode Island, Montana, Maine, New Hampshire, Idaho, West Virginia, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oregon, Kentucky, Minnesota, New York: 0
- State populations according to the U.S. Census Bureau’s 2019 population estimates
- U.S. population by state: reader-friendly list
Analyzing the per capita state list
Mathematically, five years is a small sample size when considering the entirety of college football history and All-America honorees. Hawaii, though, stands out in the crowd as the best per-capita producer of All-Americans since 2015. The state of 1.4 million has produced three in the last five seasons, including Utah’s Bradlee Anae (2019), Washington State’s Hercules Mata’afa (2017), and UCLA’s Ka’imi Fairbairn (2015).
It’s shocking that California, with a population of more than 39 million people, has produced the same number of All-Americans as Hawaii (three) since 2015. Delaware interposes itself as the fourth-best state by virtue of its small population (less than a million) and its one honoree, Pitt’s Quadree Henderson in 2016.
Pennsylvania, Michigan, and Indiana are three Big Ten and MAC-laden states that are declining in population overall and rank outside the Top 20 of U.S. states in terms of per capita All-American production.
Some of the largest states who have produced no All-Americans in the past five seasons? Take a look at New York (19.5 million people), Minnesota, Kentucky, and Oregon — all homes to decent FBS programs, but just no home-grown All-Americans in the past half-decade. Then there’s Nebraska and West Virginia: zero homegrown All-Americans in the past five years and struggling FBS state schools.
Here’s a U.S. map of football All-Americans per capita since 2015:
Read on to see the list of individual players and their home states.