DJ Lagway’s injury woes threaten the Florida Gators College Football Playoff hopes

Florida Gators quarterback DJ Lagway enters the 2025 season on the mend but if he can’t stay healthy, his absence could significantly derail the team’s ambitions. The team has lofty goals with him under center for his second season. A lot can ride on his play and presence from coaches jobs to possible championship contenders. 

Injury Timeline

In spring 2025, Lagway was held out of throwing during practice due to a persistent shoulder issue. While surgery isn’t expected before 2026, coach Billy Napier emphasized a conservative rehab approach to avoid aggravation. This could effect his confidence for throwing and running. He hasn’t shown his running ability to the level he’s accustomed to. Bracing for hits and the worry about reinjury could impact his willingness to let loose.

At fall camp (July 2025), he suffered a calf strain, leading him to start camp in a walking boot and be limited to day‑to‑day status. Coach Napier noted steady progress but no firm return date. Camp hasn’t even started yet, and he’s dealing with a lower body injury already. This is concerning because he did have other lower-body extremities injured last season.

Impact on Development & Team Preparedness

Lagway’s injuries precluded him from significant spring and early camp reps. This is critical for building chemistry with his receivers, mastering schematics, and refining reads. Timing and rhythm would be off if he misses an extensive amount of time. The Gators need to be clicking on all cylinders early and often to keep up with arguably the deepest SEC we’ve seen in years. 

Offensive Outlook Without Lagway

Backup options include Yale transfer Aidan Warner and Louisville/Tennessee journeyman Harrison Bailey. While both can be serviceable, neither has demonstrated the starting stability or play-making upside Lagway brings.

Florida’s early schedule, with games against LIU and USF, could allow a measured return. But the mid-season gauntlet includes divisions like LSU, Miami, Texas A&M, and a road date at Texas. In such matchups, a healthy Lagway might tilt the odds; without him, the Gators may struggle. If there’s already questions of whether he can stay healthy then how could he handle a physical conference schedule in the SEC. 

What’s at Stake in 2025

Upside: A fully healthy Lagway could elevate Florida into SEC championship contention. His freshman 2024 season produced nearly 2,000 passing yards and Freshman All‑American honors—and fans and Gators leadership expect a major leap this year. The way he led that Gators team during the second half of the year was very impressive. He showed maturity beyond his years, and that there’s not a throw he couldn’t make while still being slightly banged up. That stretch possibly saved Coach Napier’s job, allowing them to run it back. He has Heisman level talent.

Downside: A recurring shoulder or lower-body injury might mean limited reps, reduced cohesiveness on offense, and forced reliance on lesser-experienced backups. This would derail Florida’s season before it starts. It’s sad to say, but it’s true with how grueling their schedule is once again. Not saying they can’t be competitive, but all those aspirations of SEC title and CFP potential would go right out the window.

"Florida's stability around DJ Lagway is a big piece of the puzzle in 2025"

Billy Napier

Even Coach Napier admits that having Lagway available and healthy will be a crucial component for their team. The same can be said about every team's starting QB, but when Lagway has already missed time last year and at multiple points already for this upcoming season, that becomes a huge issue. Florida doesn’t have the luxury of having an experienced backup in Graham Mertz like they had last year.

Looking Ahead

"“When he gets back, he’ll be just fine”"

Billy Napier

This quote seems very vague and kind of cliche to say. What else is he supposed to say? Last year it took Lagway some time to find rhythm after his injury so why shouldn't people worry that could happen again this season. Napier himself notes that while injuries are unfortunate, managing Lagway’s health and rhythm carefully is essential but this only matters if he’s available to play. Florida opens its 2025 campaign on August 30 against FCS opponent LIU which is a game likely to give Lagway time to ramp up or possibly even sit to get fully healthy. But as SEC play arrives, his availability and consistency become crucial. 

DJ Lagway remains Florida’s offensive centerpiece. If he can stay healthy, the Gators project as a dark-horse contender in the SEC and possibly a playoff hopeful. But his recurring shoulder and lower-body setbacks raise real concerns about his ability to deliver sustained performance throughout 2025. A fully healthy Lagway could spark growth and drive success for this team leading to overall team confidence. A sidelined or rusty Lagway might expose Florida’s lack of depth, especially at the most important position on the field, and stall the team’s momentum only raising more questions. 

More Florida Gators News: